Kathryn House
Hello, and welcome to Talking Property with CBRE. I'm Kathryn House, your podcast host, and in this episode, I'm diving into another panel session from the Property Council Congress in Brisbane. We've already gone live with the first congress episode featuring Charter Hall CEO David Harrison. If you haven't tuned into that one, it's well worth a listen. In this episode, I'm following up on a session that went to the heart of Australia's growth challenge. How do we attract investment, lift delivery capacity, and build what a growing nation needs? Australia has just passed twenty eight million people and is on track to top forty million by 2065. The challenge is no longer working out what to build, it's creating the conditions to deliver it.
Adam Copp
The transport department claims that they're going to deliver tens of thousands of homes, but there's no defensible plan to get there in the business case or in the planning.
Kathryn House
That's Adam Copp, Chief Executive Officer of Infrastructure Australia.
Caillin Howard
Time is money as well. Right? Escalation at the moment, if you can fast track things, you can save a huge amount of money.
Kathryn House
And that's Caillin Howard, Managing Director of Hames Sharley. I hope you enjoy our conversation. Adam, welcome to Talking Property.
Adam Copp
Thanks, Kathryn. Pleasure to be here.
Kathryn House
Adam, for listeners who may not be familiar with Infrastructure Australia, can you tell us what the organisation does and give our listeners a quick feel for some of the current priorities?
Adam Copp
Sure. So we're the Australian Government's independent infrastructure adviser. So, like the Productivity Commission independently advises on productivity or the Reserve Bank independently sets interest rates. We independently advise the Australian government on infrastructure. So we provide advice across the project life cycle and their investments, so things like infrastructure strategy, project investment advice to the minister and to cabinet. We do public business case assessment and assurance and also post completion reviews of projects after they've been completed. So we take a very broad view. We cover most of the hard economic infrastructure sectors, transport, water, telco, and energy, and try and provide the best advice we can in response to some of those bigger picture issues that Australia is facing, like productivity, population growth, geopolitical change, all of those sorts of things.
Kathryn House
So, you're not busy at all at the moment, Adam.
Adam Copp
It's a fun job. Very fun job.
Kathryn House
And, Caillin, thanks for joining the show. Can you also give us, I guess, a quick snapshot of Hames Sharley and some of your current projects?
Caillin Howard
Yeah. Thanks, Kathryn. Look, Hames Sharley is one of the larger Australian design practices. We have studios in every mainland capital of the country. We're involved in circa one and a half, one point seven billion dollars worth of construction a year through the design services that we deliver, which gives us a reasonable, I suppose, look at how each state goes and how Australia is ticking along. Current interesting larger projects, the team's working on the Women and Babies Hospital in Western Australia. We're doing a couple of exciting precinct developments in South Australia being the the new Southwark suburb in Glenside. We're waiting for the announcement imminent of the two teams left in the race for AUKUS, and we're also in a two horse race that we'll find out in a couple of weeks in regards to the new prison in in the Northern Territory, as well as heavily involved in some data centres in most states currently.
Kathryn House
So a busy end of the year for you then.
Caillin Howard
Yes. And, of course, there's thousands and thousands of apartments as you would expect with, yeah, us all doing our bit to serve the housing crisis that we all find ourselves in.
Kathryn House
Yes. Which was obviously a big topic of conversation at Congress. So, Adam, you've spoken about Sydney growing to the size of New York and Melbourne becoming bigger than London. At conference, you referenced Kevin Rudd's description of Australia as the complacent country. What is the first decision that you think governments need to make now rather than in ten years' time as we are pursuing these growth ambitions?
Adam Copp
It's probably important to note that Kevin Rudd wasn't particularly talking about governments in that speech. He was really talking about our culture as a country, so all of us, business, government, voters, all of us. And when you look at so many issues that we're facing, like geopolitics or population growth or climate change or AI, a lot of times the debate seems to focus on almost burying our head in the sand and avoiding dealing with the wave that's coming. And in all of those issues, the wave is coming kind of whether we like it or not. So on population growth, my view is we really need to lean into that opportunity and, to extend the metaphor, surf the wave rather than bury our head in the sand. And, you know, there's a legitimate case to be made about the content of our immigration intake, but a growing Australia, well supported by infrastructure, will make Australia a far more productive, livable place, and it would be great to see more of a public debate of that sort of tone, in my view. Bigger cities, like the size of New York and London, that's by 2065 on current projection rates, so the intergenerational report said we'll be about forty million people by 2065. That will mean a change in how we currently live our lives. We'll need to better manage congestion by planning and delivering more mass transit. We'll need to build more housing along our mass transit lines to house people. We'll need social green and blue infrastructure to support quality of life. We'll need to manage an increased freight task, so bigger ships, deeper channels, larger, more automated ports, dedicated freight rail, and more freight on rail generally. But that's a lot of investment, but if we don't grow as a country, then we will shrink as a country, and we'll get older and poorer at the same time. So growth can be scary, but not growing is also scary as well.
Kathryn House
Mhmm. It was interesting. Josephine Sukkar from Buildcorp was on your session, and she was referencing a description she'd heard, I think, in the US of Australia as being fat, lazy Switzerland. She did push back on that, but she did warn about that lack of urgency if we fail to stimulate delivery. Caillin, do you see complacency in the way we're planning and designing our cities, or are there some deeper problems around the tools we've got?
Caillin Howard
Oh, look. A great question, Kathryn. Yeah. A bit of column a, a bit of column b, and I think Adam's response to the early question, I couldn't agree more. I think it's it's complacency served by a long period of time of not needing to worry about these things and maybe a political environment where, let's face it, infrastructure is not an overly sexy thing. It's like the IT department in your practice. You know? No one complains about it when it works, but if something goes wrong, it's the end of the world. And so I think, you know, it's really easy to sit back, and this is where I really agree with Adam. It's not a government issue. It's an Australian issue. And we need to, as constituents, be better at asking the right questions. And, yeah, look. I'm all for it. I think it's it's not about whether we're growing or we're not. We are growing, so let's make sure we're talking about the things we need to do to take advantage of that and capture it. And it is a gift. You know? Without growth, the world gets really, really difficult really, really quickly. But, yes, there is a level of complacency, be it politically driven, be it just that we've been a really well resourced and comfortable country. I'm not sure if I agree with a lazy fat Switzerland, but like with any of those things, there's a threat of truth there. Right? And if that wakes us up to stop and look at things in a more proactive way, then great. I mean, I'm gonna drop another analogy. But, you know, if you don't plan, you plan to fail. And I think that there is a lack of planning. I think that the growth that sits in each state has been amplified of late, and we are getting ourselves a little caught out. But it was something we used to be really good at. You know? A colleague of mine uses a... Well, I've now kinda robbed it and probably use it more than him, but he just reminds us that, you know, Sydney was a population of circa one point one million, one point two million. You know? That's a couple of hundred thousand less than Adelaide today when it committed to the construction of the bridge and the undergrounding of its transit system. Now you look back at that a hundred and ten years down the track or or, you know, give or take a decade, what that's done to allow that city to grow. And I'd go as far as to say what it does to entice people to come to that city. Yeah? Because the infrastructure allows, as Adam said, that growth to be positive and comfortable. You know? Like, a larger rate base through density and population growth allows, if managed properly, the ability to invest in infrastructure both behind the scenes and the fabric of a city and the amenity that those people get and the connectivity that we're able to deliver them. Now one of Australia's largest problems is we have an ideal that we should never lose, but of equity. Of the few people we have across this massive landmass, we work tirelessly to deliver the same access and services to everybody on it. And that's incredibly difficult because of the vast distances. It means that, you know, the pressure on the delivery of infrastructure is huge compared to many other countries. So population helps us with that and shares the load, but we do need to plan, and we need to quarantine that upside to reinvest in that infrastructure so it is positive all around.
Kathryn House
So let's talk a little about the housing shortage. You never open the paper without seeing a story about it. It was obviously a point of discussion at Congress. The thing that I found really interesting was this whole idea of the middle market squeeze. So, Caillin, at Congress, you said only around a quarter of approved apartments are actually getting built. And in that fortnight leading up to Congress, about thirteen hundred to fourteen hundred apartments that you were working on were put on hold, all in that middle market. What's putting the squeeze there?
Caillin Howard
And that was two weeks ago. I can say that there's been a few more in the last couple of weeks as well. Sorry, listeners. Look. There's ongoing inflation in the cost of construction. Yeah. And that's been the case since COVID. There's probably a discussion. I believe Adam's data that he shared still doesn't feel right to me, but, the skill shortage, regardless of where the infrastructure spend really is overlapping and squeezing the construction industry, there is mounting pressure and a lack of tenuous pipeline for the construction industry that continues to drive massive inflation in the cost of constructing things. With the adaption and change of the tax system, I think I did it. I think I explained that possibly carefully.
Kathryn House
You did very well.
Caillin Howard
Look. With the middling of the tax system, the other side of the coin being the value of the asset and the sales point is plateauing, reducing. So the gap between the cost of delivery and its value is tightening. And so the the affordable product that's already subsidised, you know, thankfully, by state and federal government has the room to share some of that, and the top end luxury product has the ability to share that too. And I think the luxury end of the market almost is helped by it because it's downsizing and liquefying your, the money that you have in a house, but that's not really helping where it's needed, which is the middle market.
Kathryn House
So, Adam, do you think that infrastructure planning is adequately accounting for the type of housing, so say, middle market that a project will unlock, or can that middle market fall between policy settings?
Adam Copp
Yeah. One of our roles is to publicly evaluate the business case for every Commonwealth transport investment seeking more than two hundred fifty million dollars. So, generally, the really big mega projects at least half a billion dollars. And in those business cases, contemplation of housing is very unevenly done. So sometimes there's no thought at all put into the housing outcome from a multibillion dollar transport investment. The benefits in the business case are just travel time savings, vehicle operating costs, safety outcomes, like, very transport focused, and that's pretty much it, which is a shame when you're spending tens of billions of dollars on a piece of transport infrastructure that has a really good opportunity to get more housing, particularly on that mass transit corridor. Almost worse, though, is when a transport department claims that they're gonna deliver tens of thousands of homes, but there's no defensible plan to get there in the business case or in the planning. So it's just build it and they will come, but there's no evidence of zoning changes, no evidence of engagement with the planning department. Just, you know, build it and the housing will eventually come. I think there are some bright lights. We did some post completion reviews last year on a few mass transit projects, particularly on their housing outcomes. So Canberra Light Rail has actually done a really good job delivering about six thousand homes from that investment. And partly, that's because just the structure of the ACT government, they have a lot more control centrally over the levers, the zoning changes, and those sorts of things. The northwest metro in northwest Sydney is, you know, starting to get some decent housing uplift out of that investment, which opened in 2019, so about eight years ago. So I'm near Hill Showground Station, and we're seeing apartments and middle terraces and other things opening up near Hill Showground are under construction. And that's from a focus of having a transit oriented development zoning and some big pushes from the New South Wales government on that. We think we have a bit of a role to play on this about thinking through how we can incentivise some of those behaviours from state transport departments. So putting more expectation on them to put in place some sort of defensible plan around what housing can be delivered from these, you know, massive multibillion dollar transport investments. But it is... Housing is one of those multi portfolio kind of challenges that needs some more central management within government just because of the way in which governments are traditionally structured.
Kathryn House
So, Caillin, do you think there's one intervention that could really unblock that middle market?
Caillin Howard
Oh, I wish there was a silver bullet. The chicken and egg, we almost need to have a hiccup or a readjustment. Like, the construction market needs to catch up with its access to skills. While I think certainty is a really important part of the market, sometimes having a little lack of certainty sharpens prices, sharpens approach, not having a glut of never ending future allows things to be sharper. And I think we're in a current economy where there's a group of players in it that are doing really well, and there's a group of players that are doing it very, very difficultly. And so that makes it really hard to put your finger on the pulse of where the issue is. But until we can get control of inflation, but I think construction and generally, the mechanisms that we're using to slow it down in other ways are causing the problem. So, you know, I think in Congress talked about the fact that a lot of siloed processes are working very hard at opening up infrastructure so housing can go everywhere, finding steps to deliver housing, and then we continue with our bureaucracy and legislation to ensure that we do it safer and safer every month and every year. All of those things are admirable and appropriate, but overseeing it as an umbrella and using levers of prioritisation and process, I think is important. The answer sits, I think, in a granular situation, and I was really happy in our last conversations that I had with Adam was that the work that he and his team does does look into that and does look at the prioritisation of where the biggest benefit is of the spend, but that's not always listened to as we've become to understand. So, yeah, I I think looking for a silver bullet or a big move is the incorrect answer. Like, if you turn one big thing off, there's another big thing that comes out, but I think looking at the next layer and jumping into the sentences and the paragraphs of the problem, if we could slow down on infrastructure spend and start to systematically prioritise and work it through, so not turn it off, just simmer it. If we could look at continual bureaucracy and legislation and not just look at adding to it, but also looking back into our systems to see where we could remove and turn some things off, because time is money as well. Right? Escalation at the moment, if you can fast track things, you can save a huge amount of money. But equally, there's big and small places to attack this. Yeah. In the small end of it, I think South Australia just reduced their safe working height from three metres to two metres. Like, as a sentence, you go, oh, that makes sense. But when you stop and think about it, while they haven't mandated the use of scaffolding between that gap, the need for contractors to write a safety assessment process to manage it and where insurance sits, it will almost guarantee that the solution will sit with scaffolding, which on the last basis of research will add thirty thousand dollars to the cost of a single level dwelling. So I'm not saying we shouldn't be safe, but all of these decisions have a direct relationship to the big problem we are all talking about, which is housing affordability and accessibility, and so many things are still moving ahead that are counter to it. And so where's the where's the intersection of common sense? Like, from the private sector, like, we've got ten dollars to spend. We can't go and commit to twenty dollars. And I think that politicising those things is an issue, obviously, but could we not reward those places, jurisdictions that did plan, that have got their infrastructure better advanced and give them the advantage of landing that population growth and process first rather than... It just seems like we're trying to put a fire out, and the hose is sprinkling really lightly over everything rather than focusing on a couple of those key sides. Sorry. That's a really long answer.
Kathryn House
No. No. It... Well, it's actually a good segue into priorities because I was going to ask Adam, Infrastructure Australia has a priority list. It's 68 nationally significant proposals across a whole range of things, transport, water, energy, social infrastructure. What makes one of these make the list and others not? Like, how do you do that prioritisation?
Adam Copp
So for the most recent list, and we're actually updating it at the moment, and it should come out in early twenty twenty seven. So we started by looking at all all of the megatrends, some of which I talked about before, things like changing geopolitics, population growth, climate change, productivity, and then we brought that down into five themes about the... How the different asset classes need to respond to that across freight, ports, mass transit, water, and energy. And we also took some policy positions around the types of investments that need to be made in response to those issues. So things like having more freight on rails to deal with congestion and climate change issues, port expansion and automation, seeking to have more rainfall independent sources of water, and focusing on the energy transition. And then, we work with state and territory governments and, some Commonwealth proponents. They bring forward proposals, and, we assess that against national significance, size, scope. You know, should the Australian Government be investing in this? And then, the criteria and theme. So we've got a big long list to bring it down to 68 proposals. And they're spread across three time horizons, so zero to one, two to four, and five to ten years, and then types of funding, so planning for, say, a business case or delivery to actually deliver the infrastructure. So we've tried to just kind of filter down from the sort of unlimited wants that are out there against the sort of strategy and then investing in not necessarily just delivering a piece of infrastructure and not necessarily going for it all at the same time, everything everywhere all at once. And that is advice to government. It's a phased investment pipeline based on the best evidence that we can put forward. And ultimately, though, ministers are accountable for decisions that they make about what they're going to invest in, and that's the way our system works. But we've had good response from the government on what we put forward this year and are well engaged with them on it as well. There's been other reforms to try and smooth the pipeline, particularly since that mega transport investment boom roughly three or four years ago, to better just phase the investment in infrastructure, particularly transport infrastructure. And we do a piece of work called market capacity, and we're seeing that although there's quite a lot underway under construction in, say, New South Wales and Victoria, which have been the big states, there's less in that forward pipeline. They are really trying to put more control over how much they're investing into the longer term, but there's still a lot to do. There's seventy billion dollars worth of defence investment to do. There's the Olympics up in Queensland. You know, there are a lot of other pulls on the public purse and private sector investment in things like data centres and renewable energy. So it is still, like, quite a heightened market, but governments, particularly the big governments, have been a lot more cautious in recent times about what they're going to continue to invest in longer term.
Kathryn House
So let's chat a little bit more about costs and process. It was interesting at Congress, Josephine from Buildcorp asked how much more the private sector could be shackled with and warned against layering on processes when businesses are already stretched. And, Cailin, you talked to Congress about regulation adding, you know, a hundred and thirty thousand dollars to every new home and these planning approval times that vary so widely between jurisdictions, you know, ranging from twenty days to a hundred and forty four days. So, obviously, some systems are working well and others aren't. Why is best practice so difficult to replicate?
Caillin Howard
Look. I think the twenty two days might be a bit too tight. But it does... I suppose having the benefit, like Adam, of working across the country and seeing different jurisdictions, it continues to amaze me that there seems to be a barrier between learning from each other, and maybe it's a maturity piece. Right? Like, I'll go do it myself rather than, oh, look at that. It's been done there. Again, I've been based in Adelaide for a little bit, and it blows me away how well that state has developed in regards to renewables, and it's also the state that happens to have that twenty two days next to it. I think we've got to get over ourselves in regards to state to state, And, yes, we do compete state to state on many things, but we are one country, and there's a heap to learn from one another. And we do actually use the same Australian standards and the base same NCC in regards to construction with little variances. They are the same playing fields. You know. I've got plenty of friends in every state, and then we're not all that different than one another. There's a few words and terms that are unique, but principally, we're pretty aligned. So, yeah, what... It's a good question. What is stopping the ability to share, copy, work from where things are are really good and worth sharing? I don't have the answer because it just still confuses me. Adam, what's your thoughts?
Adam Copp
Just our beautiful federation. And, yeah, I mean, you you see it very regularly across a whole range of areas. I was talking to... This is a couple of years ago, one of the states who are thinking of introducing, e scooters, which had been successfully introduced in about four other states for years. But they were doing their own trial in a particular area of that particular state just to, you know, just because, you know, it's been happily introduced in a range of other areas, but, you know, we're all very special. There is a lot. Like, there are forums that governments collaborate on through national cabinet, etcetera, and they do seek to learn from each other as well. But I think what we saw during COVID as well was our states, just in the way in which they're structured, they're almost like little countries, and they have a lot of power. And it's important to remember that the states invented the Commonwealth in 1901, not the other way around. And so they have a lot of powers and, you know, fiercely control them. But, yeah, I think, in particular, when there's a crisis, what I see is is governments do a good job collaborating. But for some reason, when the crisis seems to depart, it just kind of fades away very, very quickly. So... Yeah.
Kathryn House
So let's talk a little bit more, and you touched on it briefly, Caillin, but the skills shortage, capacity, competition. Adam, at Congress, you said we were gonna need to home grow skills as much as possible, and you called out some interesting stats in the infrastructure industry, particularly around women, that they represent only two percent of the on-site infrastructure workforce and fourteen percent of the sector overall. What changes do we need to make to shift that?
Adam Copp
Yeah. It's very... It's complex, and it will take time. Part of the reason is women aren't attracted to the sector for a range of reasons, including experiences of women over time who have actually come into the sector. And another aspect to it is the way in which the sector manages itself is not particularly flexible. And it's not just women who need flexibility. I think increasingly, people of, say, your Gen Z or even millennial generation have much higher expectations about better work life balance and flexibility, etcetera. So there was a culture and construction task force that was funded by the New South Wales and, Victorian governments a few years ago, and they did a study across a range of projects around introducing a culture standard. And there were a number of elements to it, but actually the most powerful element to changing the way in which people felt about their workplace, their construction workplace, was to move to a five day working week from a six day working week and still doing the same number of hours but actually having enough flexibility to have two days off within the week. And there was no change in terms of delivery timelines. The engineering firms and construction, they just responded to what the constraint was, and all the projects were delivered on time and on budget. And so it meant that there was a much greater level of retention, which saves money, and there was, you know, no change to the cost of the project or the delivery timeline of the project as well. So it was five or six different projects in New South Wales and Victoria, And that's now being managed through the infrastructure and transport senior officials meeting, so most states have signed up to try and implement some element of that. The ACT government has fully signed up to the standard, and certain projects in New South Wales and Victoria are still using it. So, you know, there's a number of elements to it, including issues of sexism and bullying, but setting up the workplace so it's a more attractive place for people to come to and stay will be an important element of having a homegrown workforce. And then there's other aspects around just getting more people into the pipeline, getting more people to train in STEM throughout the engineering side or the consulting side, getting more people exposed to the opportunities in engineering and construction as well. But the people that we do get, we need to make sure that we retain as much as possible.
Kathryn House
Give us your thoughts, Caillin, on the the skills side.
Caillin Howard
Yeah. Sorry to be, consistent, but obviously agree with Adam completely there. And we've had to go on our own journeys and change and a lot of things over the last decade that a decade ago we said we couldn't do in regards to flexibility, in regards to equality, supporting is now commonplace. And setting goals and demanding targets and change, it's amazing how quickly we can change. But... So I agree with Adam that all of us and all industries need to continue to do that, but there is also contextual issues that we need to navigate that are beyond that. And I think that's... It's pretty simple. It's almost talked about as much as the housing affordability issue. We have a a trade skill shortage from decades of biasing, you know, university pathways, and we're working on bringing that back, but there's a lag in doing that, and we find ourselves in the middle of it. What I also have observed for some time, which is quite confronting and confusing for a little old architect that locks colour in and draw pictures, is that I've met a number of people state and federally based over the last decade that have been tasked with, you know, investigating skill recognition and fast tracking process from the people that do come from outside here. And yet it seems to have a twelve, eighteen month shelf life and the excitement and focus just gets trodden on and dissipates from the bureaucracy that sits around it and not enabling it. Surely, we're at a point in time where we need to take that seriously and approach it in a can do rather than a safe, risk adverse, oh, it's just to be difficult, and we'll solve it another way. So I think that's a huge piece of work that should be elevated to being taken a lot more seriously than it has. And the other one that, you know, through Committee of Adelaide and a few other boards I'm involved in, observing and seeing the numbers that don't translate in regards to international students in this country and them finding, you know, appropriate and meaningful use of those studies in Australia. And that's more confronting than being called fat, lazy Switzerland. Right? Like, bottom line is we do not yet appropriately give people a chance that come here and study here because I would suggest we're uncomfortable because they look a little different or they speak a little differently, and that is ridiculous. It shouldn't be the case, but it is. So what are we doing to change it? How are we demanding that all of that proximity and access to intelligence and productivity is not unlocked? Like, South Australia has an appointed minister for autism because in that jurisdiction, they're understanding that the value and power of productivity and intelligence that actually sits within that particular neurodiverse stream is worth focusing on and connecting with workplace and creating an understanding of the importance of an environment and a context change to enable that to be harnessed in the workplace. I think it's fantastic, but if we can do it for a neurodiverse component of our possible workforce, surely, we can apply the same approach to our international students and that transfer and trust that, you know, that's not there. So there's a lot of answers to the problems we've got at our fingertips, but we're just not joining the dots.
Kathryn House
So let's finish off with... We have to go to it, data centres. Again, you can't open the paper any day without reading about it. So, Adam, you used at Congress data centres as an example of the complexity involved in projects, which involve all these multiple layers of government. So in the case of data centres, departments that focus on the water side, chips, fiber, etcetera, is there an easy way to cut through the complexity here when it comes to data centres?
Adam Copp
Yeah. I mean, we looked at the growth of data centres and AI as part of our priority list earlier this year, and it's it's been amazing how quickly, in comparison to many other issues, governments have responded to the issues. So I think that data centre operators and people in property probably would like it to be twice as fast, if not more, but it is a complex area for governments to grapple with just because the way in which data centres consume so much from the... Particularly the other hard economic infrastructure sectors, you know, energy, water, fibre. There's a transport aspect to it, which is, you know, is this the best use of the particular land where the data centre will be, or should it be used for some sort of logistics need or something else? And then just broad geopolitical and industry policy type issues as well. And then it's levels of government as well. So it covers a lot of different complex areas. It's a very systems thinking type issue. The Australian Government sought to put in place national standards and have sought agreement through national cabinet around those, and then they're going to seek to legislate those national standards. And they will seek to standardise the type of energy that people will source and the way in which they interact with the state governments and others, which, when I've engaged with a lot of the bigger data centre operators, they've actually welcomed that certainty because it just means that the rules of the game are clear and that they can then execute, and it kind of flushes out some of the phantom demand that is in the pipeline. Because if you believe what's in the pipeline, all we will be doing for the next ten years is constructing data centres, and that just won't be true. So it is a very complex problem. The way in which governments... So the Federal Government has centred AI policy in the Department of Prime Minister and cabinet, so the prime minister's area is is running it. It's the Office of AI. They're going to seek to legislate those standards, so they'll apply across the country. Many states and territories have put in place coordinator general roles who can cut across different parts of government, the water, the energy. So South Australia and WA have coordinated generals. Victoria has an investment coordinator general as well. But it is pulling together lots of different strands because it's not just government. You've also got these regulated, say, energy providers like TransGrid in New South Wales who have a role to play, and they put in place their own standards of what they would expect to see as well. So it's an asset class unlike one I have really seen in infrastructure. It's amazing how much it consumes from the other sectors, but the opportunity from it as well, I'm very bullish on. We're gonna do some more work on this in our next priority list around how do we diffuse some of the benefits of AI through the infrastructure sector more effectively because, you know, there's so many benefits to riding this wave of investment that's coming our way. We can pull forward some of the renewable energy projects that might be stuck before a final investment decision. We can diffuse some of this technology through the economy more broadly and improve our pretty low productivity rates as well. So, again, kind of like population growth, I think we really need to seek to engage with this investment wave and surf it rather than bury our head in the sand and try and shut them all down because there's just a lot of opportunities here if we're willing to really engage with the issue.
Kathryn House
Caillin, give us your view on the data centre sector.
Caillin Howard
Well, I must admit, I'm feeling better and better after listening to Adam just then. All the things we talked about at the beginning of this discussion was a... You know, a lot of it was about competition and nonalignment across the country. And so to hear, you know, and aware of those things, creating a sense of fairness and consistency, clarity across the country and how we approach this, I think, is a really, really good thing. Gotta make sure that that's done in a way that both protects our needs locally as a country, but also sets up our ability to compete in that tech world internationally, which is the knife edge that's floating and sitting. I mean, yeah, it turns out that the fluffy white cloud that we store everything in is not quite so fluffy and as white, but it's a beautiful marketing slang. But, I mean, we've become very reliant on it and the future of unlocking the automation and the intelligence that's available and continues to grow exponentially relies on it. But... Yeah. Look. I mean, the data centre operators of which a number we work with have been very aware of this. I think we did a piece of research and wrote some papers a couple of years ago about the need to understand the consumption and impact of these things and sort of saw this issue coming. You know, nuclear will need to be considered moving forward. I think, you know, part of the spin off of the investment we're putting into defence, yes, it's around submarines, but it's also around understanding, you know, small reactors and the ability of another power source. So, yeah, that... That's certainly not a one trick pony in regards to the future, but it's a fair way away. But we do need to prioritise the needs to eat, the needs to supply infrastructure for housing. You know, we can probably, for a small period of time, rely on a few extra milliseconds of lag to our answer on Google or Siri over how to house a few more thousand million people that occupy the continent. So, yeah, I'm all for a central level of clarity and management of that because I think without it, the competition between the states and the competition between public and private could really have this runaway further than it already has. So I think we're on the right track there.
Adam Copp
In our engagement, time to power was, like, the primary issue the data centere operators were having as as their issue, but social license is is probably right up there as as a key risk that needs to be managed. And, you know, without going into any individual cases of recent data centres that have had community pushback and then they've had to pull the investment. Just creating a a sense from government but also from the sector that we're gonna do this in an orderly way with people at the centre of it, and we're listening, and there's so many... And then talking about the benefits of the investment as well, I just think will be a really important part of taking up the opportunity of this private sector investment.
Caillin Howard
Yeah. In a way, we're at the nexus of it. Right? Like, I mean, obviously, this week, you said announcements, but the data centre operators need the social license and support. They're incredibly volatile in regards to public listings and share values and ability to deliver. So, yeah, I think a public private position where the clarity of, yes, it is being managed, yes, it is being done in a sustainable monitored way that balances the other competing interests for the infrastructure that it impacts is needed for them to continue down that road. So, yeah, I think in a rare moment, the stars are somewhat aligned in all parties' needs, and things are happening as they need to happen.
Kathryn House
Well, I think that was a great way to finish off today. Caillin, it was great to have you on the show. Thank you so much for joining.
Caillin Howard
Thanks, Kathryn.
Kathryn House
And, Adam, I really appreciated your insights both today and at the Congress.
Adam Copp
Thank you, Kathryn. Appreciate it.
Kathryn House
So if there's one message I think from today's conversation, it's that the challenge isn't knowing what Australia needs to build. It's choosing priorities, sequencing decisions, and creating the capacity to deliver them. You can find early details of next year's Property Council Congress in our episode notes. And if you don't already subscribe to Talking Property, make sure to do so so you don't miss our end of year episode on capital markets activity as well as our Property Predictions series to kick off 2027. Until next time.